Why Pulisic Losing USMNT Captaincy Isn’t a Big Deal

Christian Pulisic may be widely known as “Captain America,” but Christian Pulisic missing out on the USMNT World Cup captaincy for 2026 would not necessarily signal a crisis for the U.S. Men’s National Team. As Brad Friedel, the former USMNT stalwart, recently pointed out, leadership in football is about much more than a single armband—especially under coaches who value collective responsibility like Mauricio Pochettino.

Christian Pulisic and the USMNT Captaincy Debate

Christian Pulisic has demonstrated his leadership by captaining both club and country on various occasions. His influence in the senior squad is unquestioned, but the role of captain for the USMNT at the 2026 World Cup remains undecided. With the tournament set to take place on American soil, the discussion around who should wear the armband is in full swing.

Pulisic’s commitment to the national team is evident despite his decision to skip Gold Cup duty this year. Now playing at AC Milan, he continues to mature on and off the pitch, bringing invaluable experience from Europe’s top leagues to the USMNT setup.

Mauricio Pochettino’s Philosophy: “11 Leaders” on the Pitch

Mauricio Pochettino, known for his emphasis on collective leadership, has often stressed the importance of shared responsibility within his teams. His philosophy was clear during his time at clubs like Tottenham and PSG, and it resonates with the current USMNT approach. Rather than relying on one standout leader, Pochettino seeks to cultivate “11 leaders” who each take ownership on the field.

This model aligns with the evolving culture of the USMNT, in which leadership is distributed among a talented, increasingly experienced core. The squad now boasts European-based players like Weston McKennie, Tyler Adams, and Sergiño Dest—all of whom have worn the armband and displayed leadership qualities.

Leadership Beyond the Armband

Brad Friedel, who has seen the USMNT captaincy evolve over the years, believes that whether Christian Pulisic is officially named captain or not, his influence will remain. “It’s about much more than a title,” Friedel explained. “The best teams have several voices in the dressing room, all pushing each other to be better.”

This sentiment is echoed in the modern game, where captains are often seen as facilitators and motivators rather than strict decision-makers. The USMNT’s young squad, filled with players excelling across Europe, reflects this shift. Pulisic, as one of the most recognizable and accomplished American players, continues to inspire teammates regardless of his official title.

Pulisic’s Role at AC Milan and Its Impact on the USMNT

Pulisic’s move to AC Milan has further enhanced his reputation as a top-tier talent. He has adapted quickly to the demands of Serie A, providing crucial contributions both in attack and as a leader in the dressing room. His European pedigree and high-level experience are assets to the USMNT, preparing him to guide younger players through the pressures of a home World Cup.

Despite not participating in the Gold Cup, Pulisic’s dedication to the national team has never been questioned. His performances in World Cup qualifiers and the Nations League have showcased his ability to deliver under pressure, reinforcing his role as a leader by example.

The Broader Leadership Group Within the USMNT

While Pulisic is often the focal point, the USMNT boasts a wealth of leadership options. Tyler Adams has grown into a natural captain, marshaling the midfield with authority. Weston McKennie brings energy and grit, motivating those around him. Veterans like Tim Ream and Matt Turner provide guidance and composure at the back.

This depth of leadership reflects the team-first mentality fostered by recent USMNT managers and underlines Friedel’s point: the absence of Pulisic as captain would be far from catastrophic. The squad is built on collective strength and shared standards, rather than reliance on a single figurehead.

Looking Ahead to the 2026 World Cup

As anticipation builds for the 2026 World Cup, the USMNT’s leadership structure will be scrutinized, but the focus remains on team unity and performance. The ultimate choice of captain could be made closer to the tournament, allowing for natural leaders to emerge as the squad evolves.

Pulisic’s embrace of his role—whether as captain or not—sets a positive example for younger players. His maturity and professionalism ensure he remains an inspirational figure in the locker room, and his impact on American soccer continues to grow.

For more insights on football and global coverage, visit our homepage for more news.

Opinion: Leadership by Committee Is the Way Forward

In my view, the USMNT’s shift to a model of shared leadership is not only pragmatic but essential for success in modern football. While Christian Pulisic’s star quality is undeniable, the depth of leaders throughout the squad bodes well for their chances in 2026. With or without the captain’s armband, Pulisic will remain central to the team’s ambitions—and that’s what matters most.