Should Man Utd Re-Hire Ole Gunnar Solskjaer as Manager?

Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has become a hot topic among Red Devils supporters, with many questioning whether a return for the Norwegian could be the solution to the club’s current woes. Manchester United have endured the worst start to a Premier League season in over three decades under current boss Ruben Amorim. Despite a transfer spree of £200 million in the summer, results and performances have failed to meet expectations, leading to mounting pressure on Amorim and calls for a familiar face to steady the ship.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s Manchester United Legacy

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s first spell as Manchester United manager began in December 2018. He was initially appointed as a caretaker but his impressive run of results secured him the full-time post. Solskjaer led the team to a second-place Premier League finish in the 2020-21 season, restoring attacking football reminiscent of the Sir Alex Ferguson era. The Norwegian also guided United to the Europa League final, though they fell short against Villarreal. Solskjaer’s approach was lauded for its counter-attacking flair and for revitalizing the club’s culture, even if silverware ultimately eluded him.

Do Second Stints at Football Clubs Work?

The idea of rehiring former managers is not unique to Manchester United. Across football, several clubs have turned to familiar faces in times of crisis, with varying degrees of success. The likes of Jose Mourinho at Chelsea, Zinedine Zidane at Real Madrid, and Jupp Heynckes at Bayern Munich all returned to their former clubs—some to great effect, others with less acclaim.

Success Stories: Zidane, Heynckes, and Beyond

Zinedine Zidane’s return to Real Madrid is perhaps the most notable recent example of success. In his second stint, Zidane reclaimed the Champions League and La Liga titles, reinstating Madrid’s dominance in Europe. Similarly, Jupp Heynckes led Bayern Munich to an historic treble in his third spell at the club, demonstrating that experience, trust, and an intimate knowledge of club culture can sometimes pay dividends.

Mixed Fortunes: Mourinho, Dalglish, and Ranieri

However, not all second comings yield positive results. Jose Mourinho’s return to Chelsea brought one Premier League title, but his tenure ended in turmoil. Kenny Dalglish’s emotional return to Liverpool saw a League Cup win but little else. Claudio Ranieri’s second spell at Valencia also failed to recapture his earlier magic. These examples highlight risks associated with nostalgia-driven appointments, where the football landscape and dressing room dynamics may have shifted significantly since the manager’s previous reign.

Manchester United’s Current Struggles Under Ruben Amorim

Ruben Amorim was seen as a progressive, modern coach when he was appointed by Manchester United. However, the club’s dismal start to the season has left fans and pundits questioning his tactical rigidity and management style. Despite heavy investment in new talent, the Red Devils sit uncomfortably in the bottom half of the Premier League table. Reports suggest that Amorim has just three games to turn things around, heightening speculation about potential replacements.

Why Solskjaer Is Being Considered Again

Solskjaer’s previous tenure saw improvement in both results and team morale. His focus on youth development, counter-attacking football, and respect for Manchester United’s traditions made him a popular figure among supporters. Many believe that his deep understanding of the club’s culture could help restore stability and identity at Old Trafford, especially during turbulent times.

Should Manchester United Re-Hire Ole Gunnar Solskjaer?

The prospect of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer returning to Manchester United divides opinion. Supporters who remember the optimism and progress of his first period in charge are hopeful that he could rekindle that spirit. Critics, however, argue that the club needs a fresh direction and that repeated returns to the past risk stagnation.

Expert Opinion: Tread Carefully with Nostalgic Appointments

Drawing from the experiences of clubs like Real Madrid, Chelsea, and Bayern Munich, it’s clear that bringing back a former manager can work—but only under the right conditions. The club must consider whether the current squad, boardroom, and culture are compatible with Solskjaer’s methods. Football has a short memory, and what worked before may not be effective in a rapidly evolving Premier League landscape.

Ultimately, while Solskjaer’s affinity for Manchester United and his previous achievements make him a tempting candidate, the club must weigh emotional sentiment against the need for tactical innovation and long-term planning. If United believe Solskjaer can both inspire the squad and adapt to new challenges, a second stint could succeed. Otherwise, the risk of repeating past mistakes looms large.

For ongoing updates on this developing story and more football news, visit for more news.

Final Thoughts

While the allure of a familiar face like Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is strong, Manchester United must ensure any managerial decision is based on strategy, not sentiment. The club’s future depends on learning from history—both its triumphs and its missteps.