MLS Must Improve to Become a Top-Five Football League

Major League Soccer faces a critical crossroads as Columbus Crew owner Jimmy Haslam openly questions its standing among the world’s elite leagues. His recent comments have reignited the debate about whether MLS truly delivers a product capable of joining the ranks of global football’s top five competitions—a conversation that continues to shape the trajectory of American soccer.

MLS’s Place in Global Football

Major League Soccer, though steadily growing in popularity and infrastructure, has yet to be universally recognized alongside football juggernauts like England’s Premier League, Spain’s La Liga, Germany’s Bundesliga, Italy’s Serie A, and France’s Ligue 1. Jimmy Haslam, owner of both the Columbus Crew and NFL’s Cleveland Browns, was candid in his assessment. “MLS is not amongst the top leagues,” Haslam stated, emphasizing that reaching such a status demands more than mere expansion—it requires a significant uplift in quality.

Haslam’s Call for a Better Product in Major League Soccer

Haslam argues the league must “put a better product on the field” if it hopes to attract consistent attention both domestically and internationally. Critics and supporters alike often point to the league’s lack of star power, tactical sophistication, and competitive intensity as barriers to MLS breaking into the global top tier. While MLS has made strides in bringing international players and investing in youth development, Haslam suggests these efforts need to be amplified for tangible results.

TV Viewership and Fan Engagement Challenges

One of the largest hurdles facing Major League Soccer is its struggle to capture robust and regular television audiences. Despite increased media deals and the high-profile arrival of international stars in recent years, ratings have not met expectations. Haslam believes that only by enhancing the league’s quality can MLS foster the kind of passionate fan engagement seen in Europe and South America. Without compelling competition and must-see matches, American viewers may continue to look abroad for their football fix.

Could Promotion and Relegation Transform MLS?

A notable suggestion from Haslam is the adoption of a promotion-relegation system—a staple in most top football leagues worldwide. Currently, MLS operates as a closed league, with no promotion from lower divisions or relegation for underperforming teams. Haslam posits that implementing such a system would inject drama and stakes into every match, potentially boosting viewer interest and raising the overall intensity of competition. However, the proposal faces obstacles, including franchise investment models and logistical complexities unique to North American sports.

Investment and Infrastructure: The Road Ahead

Major League Soccer has made significant strides in infrastructure, with modern stadiums, training facilities, and academy systems blossoming across the league. Owners like Haslam have invested heavily in their clubs, recognizing that world-class facilities and development pipelines are crucial for long-term growth. Yet, Haslam maintains this progress must translate to what happens on the pitch. The product—player quality, match excitement, and tactical innovation—remains the ultimate test of MLS’s ambition.

Comparing MLS to Football’s Elite Leagues

The gap between MLS and football’s top leagues is evident in several metrics: player salaries, transfer spending, global reach, and the quality of play. While MLS has made inroads by recruiting international icons, the average squad depth and league-wide skill level still lag behind Europe’s finest. Haslam’s comments serve as a reminder that investments off the pitch must be matched by evolution on it, if the league’s top-five aspirations are to be realized.

Opinion: A Path for MLS to Join Football’s Elite

Major League Soccer’s potential is undeniable. Its diverse fan base, expanding footprint, and increasing investment lay a strong foundation for growth. However, to truly become a top-five league, MLS must embrace bold reforms and focus relentlessly on quality. Haslam’s suggestion of a promotion-relegation system may seem radical, but it underscores the need for innovation. If league leadership takes these criticisms to heart, prioritizing player development, competitive structure, and global partnerships, MLS could one day stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the world’s best.

For more insights on global football developments and Major League Soccer’s evolution, visit for more news.