Man Utd Eye McTominay Return Amidst Napoli Success

Scott McTominay transfer rumors are heating up as Manchester United reportedly seek to bring their former midfielder back from Napoli, despite having let him go only a year ago. The Scotland international, who joined the Serie A champions in a £26 million move in 2024, has flourished in Italy, sparking debate about whether United made a costly error by sanctioning his departure.

Scott McTominay Transfer: A Rising Star in Serie A

Since leaving Old Trafford, McTominay has become an integral part of Napoli’s midfield. The 28-year-old has not only clinched the Serie A title but also delivered a career-best season, racking up 13 goals across all competitions and earning the league’s MVP honors. His blend of physicality, tenacity, and attacking flair has made him a fan favorite in Naples.

Reports indicate that McTominay and his partner Cam Reading have faced some challenges settling into their second year in Italy, fueling speculation about his future. Despite his current success, the midfielder is reportedly attracting interest from several elite clubs, including Manchester United, Barcelona, Newcastle United, and Tottenham Hotspur.

Manchester United’s Interest in the Scott McTominay Transfer

The Red Devils’ desire to re-sign McTominay underscores their recognition of his value and perhaps an admission of a hasty decision to let him go. The asking price for his return has risen significantly, with Napoli valuing him at around £44 million—substantially more than the initial transfer fee.

Former United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, who gave McTominay 115 appearances, has voiced his surprise at the original sale. He emphasized McTominay’s versatility and home-grown stature as vital assets, stating: “He sets the standard in the dressing room and on the pitch. In Italy, he’s shown how good he can be when played in his best role.”

On the other hand, ex-United captain Roy Keane remains skeptical, suggesting that while McTominay has impressed abroad, bringing him back might not solve all of United’s midfield issues.

Competition for McTominay’s Signature

Interest in McTominay extends beyond Manchester. Barcelona are reportedly monitoring him as a potential midfield addition, while Newcastle and Tottenham are eager to bolster their squads with his proven Premier League experience. According to sources close to the transfer market, “There is concrete interest in Scott McTominay from several top clubs, with Manchester United leading the chase but facing stiff competition.”

McTominay’s Napoli Contract and Current Form

Currently, McTominay remains under contract with Napoli until 2028, and the Italian champions have shown no inclination to sell. He has continued to shine, scoring four more goals in the current campaign and forming strong partnerships at Stadio Diego Armando Maradona with Rasmus Hojlund and Kevin De Bruyne.

Despite transfer rumors, McTominay remains focused on helping Scotland secure qualification for the 2026 World Cup, with crucial fixtures against Greece and Denmark on the horizon.

Homegrown Talent: Did United Make a Mistake?

The debate rages on among Manchester United supporters and pundits. Some believe the club failed to appreciate McTominay’s unique qualities and leadership, while others argue that cashing in was a logical move given his role as a squad player. The sharp rise in his market value and his on-field achievements in Italy lend weight to the argument that United may have underestimated his potential impact.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s remarks highlight the importance of having homegrown players who understand the club’s culture, while Roy Keane’s reservations exemplify a more cautious approach to bringing former players back into the fold. The answer may depend on United’s long-term vision for their midfield and whether McTominay fits the profile of player they now require.

Transfer Market Implications and What Lies Ahead

Should Manchester United move decisively to re-sign McTominay, they would face not only financial obstacles but also stiff competition from other European giants. For Napoli, retaining their star midfielder is crucial as they seek continued dominance in Serie A and stronger Champions League campaigns.

For readers seeking the latest updates on this and other breaking football news, visit for more news.

Opinion: A Move Worth Making?

In my view, Manchester United’s renewed interest in Scott McTominay highlights the need for stability and homegrown leadership in their squad. While his departure was seen by some as a pragmatic decision, his growth in Italy and current market value suggest that United may well regret letting him go. Re-signing McTominay would send a positive message about valuing club culture and player development, but only if he fits into the club’s tactical plans moving forward.