Red Bulls Hesitate on Timo Werner as MLS Move Stalls

Timo Werner transfer talks have cooled as the New York Red Bulls revealed they are “not 100% sold” on acquiring the German international in the upcoming January transfer window. The RB Leipzig striker, previously linked with a move to Major League Soccer after being sidelined in Germany, now faces significant hurdles in his quest for revival in the United States.

Timo Werner Transfer Talks Hit Wall with New York Red Bulls

The pursuit of Timo Werner by the New York Red Bulls has reached an impasse. Despite being Leipzig’s all-time leading scorer with 113 goals, Werner finds himself out of manager Ole Werner’s plans and desperate for a new challenge. Initial hopes of landing in MLS were fueled by Red Bulls’ summer negotiations, during which a two-and-a-half-year contract was discussed. However, those talks broke down due to Werner’s high wage demands, and a subsequent winter approach now looks unlikely.

Red Bulls’ Strategic Shift and Squad Dynamics

A key factor in the collapse of the Timo Werner transfer is an organizational reset at New York Red Bulls. Julian de Guzman, the club’s new head of sport, confirmed that despite the striker’s pedigree, the club was not fully convinced the move aligned with their long-term vision. De Guzman told The Athletic, “It’s a great name to bring, I think fans would have loved him, but we were not 100 percent sold that this was the right thing for New York.”

This hesitancy reflects a broader strategy shift at the Red Bulls. After missing the playoffs for the first time in 15 seasons and facing criticism for not utilizing their third Designated Player (DP) slot, the club is focused on patient, sustainable roster building. De Guzman emphasized, “I am far from wanting to sign a ‘famous player’. I simply want someone who will help the team improve,” citing the presence of experienced DPs Emil Forsberg and Eric-Maxim Choupo-Moting as reasons not to add another veteran attacker at this time.

Coaching Changes and Future Planning

The Timo Werner transfer uncertainty comes amid sweeping changes at the Red Bulls. Following the departure of head coach Sandro Schwarz, the search for a new manager is underway, with former Philadelphia Union boss Jim Curtin and internal candidate Michael Bradley both being considered. Bradley, who recently led Red Bulls II to the MLS Next Pro Cup, has drawn praise for his leadership style and tactical approach.

Squad needs remain, with the club seeking reinforcements on the wings, in midfield, and a replacement for departed goalkeeper Carlos Coronel. Yet, the leadership has chosen to keep their DP slot open for now, prioritizing fit and future growth over high-profile signings.

Timo Werner’s MLS Hopes: Next Steps After Red Bulls’ Decision

As the window closes with New York, Werner and his representatives are exploring other MLS destinations. Reports from Germany suggest the forward is considering franchises in Los Angeles and other major markets that can offer both the salary and central role he’s seeking. Despite Leipzig and Werner both agreeing on the need for a January exit, the path is far from clear. The appeal of MLS remains strong for Werner due to its lifestyle benefits and opportunities for leading roles, but finding the right fit is proving challenging.

Opinion: Red Bulls’ Conservative Approach May Pay Off

From a strategic standpoint, the Red Bulls’ reluctance to sign Timo Werner, despite his high profile, appears prudent. With the team undergoing a cultural and tactical shift, investing in the right long-term piece is more valuable than a marquee name who may not fit the evolving project. For Werner, an MLS move still makes sense, but it will likely require flexibility and the right match between his ambitions and a club’s vision.

For more updates on transfer news and football insights, visit for more news.