Palhinha Responds to Carragher Criticism Using Ronaldo Example

Joao Palhinha Fires Back at Jamie Carragher Over Criticism

Joao Palhinha, Tottenham Hotspur’s dynamic midfielder, has responded forcefully to recent criticism from Jamie Carragher, using Cristiano Ronaldo’s own experiences to make his point. The Bayern Munich loanee, enjoying a resurgence with Spurs, addressed Carragher’s negative comments and defended his performances in the Premier League.

Joao Palhinha’s Season at Tottenham Under the Microscope

Palhinha’s journey this season has been eventful. After a difficult year at Bayern Munich marked by injuries and inconsistent form, the Portugal international has made a strong return to the Premier League with Tottenham. Featuring in 18 matches across all competitions, Palhinha has recorded four goals and two assists, including a memorable strike against Manchester City.

However, not all observers have been convinced. Following Tottenham’s 1-0 home defeat to Chelsea, Sky Sports pundit and former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher openly criticized Palhinha’s display. Carragher remarked, “Palhinha hasn’t got the quality. For a player playing for Tottenham in central midfield, for me, that’s a pass you have to be able to make. He can’t make it.”

Carragher’s Comments Spark Palhinha’s Response

Carragher’s analysis did not sit well with Palhinha. The midfielder, who helped Portugal during international duty and is now a key figure at Spurs, addressed the criticism head-on in a recent interview. “I saw it because some people sent it to me, I can’t say I didn’t see it,” Palhinha explained. “I don’t care what people say. If he speaks bad things about Ronaldo, he can speak about everyone. Some people need to speak about others to be on TV. My life is not about that, definitely.”

Palhinha pointed out the trend of ex-players being overly critical: “It’s a bit embarrassing sometimes seeing ex-players speak that way. They talk as if they were superstars in their past. I think Carragher should have watched more of my Tottenham games. I believe I am having a top season.”

Palhinha Uses Ronaldo as Reference Point

In defending himself, Palhinha referenced fellow countryman Cristiano Ronaldo, highlighting that even world-class players are not immune to pundit scrutiny. “If Carragher criticizes Ronaldo, then anyone can be a target. There are always people trying to bring us down, but it’s about how we respond,” he stated.

Palhinha underlined his approach to criticism by pointing to his response on the pitch: “The way I reacted was by scoring a goal after he said those things, against Copenhagen. I just want to keep doing my job and show what I do best because I’m truly proud of what I’ve achieved so far.”

Palhinha’s Revival and Tottenham’s Transfer Plans

Tottenham’s faith in Palhinha appears to be paying off. Since joining on loan from Bayern, he has established himself as a key player under manager Thomas Frank. His physical presence, tactical intelligence, and improved attacking output have made him a valuable asset for Spurs.

Reports indicate that Tottenham are now in advanced negotiations with Bayern Munich to make Palhinha’s move permanent. The London club is reportedly willing to pay around £25 million (€30 million/$33 million), although Bayern’s final decision on the transfer remains pending. Whether the deal is finalized in the winter window or next summer is still uncertain, but Palhinha’s performances have certainly increased his value in north London.

How Palhinha’s Bayern Move Shaped His Career

Palhinha initially joined Bayern Munich from Fulham in the summer of 2024 for approximately £47 million. The move was intended to strengthen Bayern’s midfield, pairing him with stars like Joshua Kimmich and Leon Goretzka. However, adaptation issues and injuries restricted Palhinha to just 25 appearances last season, with only 10 as starts. Seen as a disappointing transfer in Munich, his loan to Tottenham was a chance at redemption—and he has seized it.

Palhinha Focused on Delivering for Spurs

As Tottenham prepare for the upcoming north London derby against Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium, Palhinha remains unfazed by outside criticism. His focus is firmly on contributing to his team’s objectives and proving his worth in the Premier League. “We are really motivated and have everything to reach a good result,” he emphasized.

For more news on Tottenham, the Premier League, and global football, visit for more news.

Opinion: Palhinha’s Response Shows Maturity

Palhinha’s reaction to Carragher’s criticism is a testament to his professionalism and mental resilience. By referencing Ronaldo and letting his performances do the talking, Palhinha has demonstrated that the best way to silence doubters is on the pitch. His journey is a reminder that players can overcome adversity and negative press to thrive at the highest level.