Man Utd Player Ratings: Red Devils Falter Against 10-Man Everton

Manchester United player ratings offer little comfort after Erik ten Hag’s side crashed to a 1-0 home defeat against an Everton team down to ten men for most of the match. From Bruno Fernandes’ subdued display to Joshua Zirkzee’s missed opportunity, the Red Devils’ struggles were visible as Goodison Park’s visitors left with all three points.

Manchester United Player Ratings vs Everton

Manchester United player ratings are a stark reflection of a disappointing evening at Old Trafford. Despite Everton’s Idrissa Gueye receiving a straight red card in the 13th minute for a bizarre altercation with teammate Michael Keane, United failed to assert themselves. Instead, they allowed Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall to score a sensational long-range strike, ultimately deciding the fixture.

First Half: Manchester United Fail to Capitalize on Advantage

Everton stormed out of the blocks, dominating possession and territory in the first ten minutes. Even after being reduced to ten men—when Gueye was sent off for striking Keane in the face—United appeared unable to seize control. The only notable United attacks came when Casemiro fired a rare shot, and Patrick Dorgu and Amad missed promising chances.

Key Defensive Performances Assessed

Senne Lammens (5/10) did little wrong but was unable to stop Dewsbury-Hall’s powerful effort. Matthijs de Ligt (4/10) was hesitant and failed to press the Everton goalscorer. Leny Yoro (4/10) let Dewsbury-Hall regain possession too easily in the buildup to the goal. Luke Shaw (4/10) struggled to contain Iliman Ndiaye, and his deliveries into the box lacked quality.

Midfield Fails to Find Creativity

United’s midfield, featuring Bruno Fernandes, Casemiro, and Noussair Mazraoui, lacked spark and control. Mazraoui (4/10) was largely ineffective before being subbed at halftime. Casemiro (4/10) failed to disrupt Everton’s rhythm, while Fernandes (3/10) endured one of his poorest showings, offering little urgency and missing a key chance in the second half. Patrick Dorgu (4/10) wasted a brilliant chance and was ineffective going forward.

Attack Shows Little Threat

Bryan Mbeumo (6/10) showed some determination but lacked composure in front of goal. Joshua Zirkzee (4/10), given a rare opportunity to lead the line, was largely anonymous until late in the game when Pickford denied him twice. Amad Diallo (6/10) had moments of inspiration but was isolated in the opening period.

Manchester United Player Ratings: Substitutes and Manager

Mason Mount (6/10) injected urgency and energy, nearly equalizing late on. Kobbie Mainoo (5/10) failed to make an impact. Diogo Dalot (5/10) added balance but failed to threaten. Coach Ruben Amorim (4/10) will face criticism for a lack of tactical adjustment, as United looked uninspired despite the numerical advantage.

What Does This Mean for Manchester United?

This defeat leaves Manchester United marooned in 10th place in the Premier League, missing a golden chance to climb higher after positive results earlier in the month. The lack of creativity, conviction, and leadership was evident across the pitch. The home crowd’s boos at the final whistle reflected a team that has lost its way.

Everton, despite the early turmoil, demonstrated resilience, pressing United and defending resolutely after the red card. Manager Sean Dyche will be delighted with his team’s togetherness and Dewsbury-Hall’s stunning goal.

Opinion: Red Devils Must Respond After Another Setback

Manchester United player ratings highlight a collective failure in mindset and performance. When facing ten men for more than 75 minutes at Old Trafford, a club with United’s ambitions must do better. The lack of urgency and belief was palpable, and the pressure will mount on Erik ten Hag to find solutions before the gap to Champions League places widens further. The team needs to rediscover the energy and focus shown in earlier matches if they are to revive their season. For more analysis, match reports, and updates on Manchester United and the Premier League, visit for more news.