Jonathan David and Weston McKennie Struggle for Juventus Impact

Jonathan David and Weston McKennie: Juventus’ CONCACAF Dilemma

Jonathan David and Weston McKennie, two of CONCACAF’s brightest stars, are yet to find consistent form at Juventus, raising questions as the World Cup approaches. The Canadian striker and the USMNT midfielder both made crucial contributions in Juve’s recent 3-2 Champions League victory, but their overall impact remains under scrutiny.

The Current State of Juventus’ CONCACAF Duo

On Tuesday night, McKennie broke the deadlock against Bodo/Glimt with a well-timed equalizer, showcasing his knack for decisive plays. Shortly after, David clinched all three points with a stoppage-time winner, rescuing Juventus from an embarrassing slip. Despite these moments, both players’ journeys in Turin have been fraught with uncertainty. McKennie, a versatile presence, often finds himself used across different roles without a defined position. David, meanwhile, is battling for minutes in a squad brimming with attacking talent.

Juventus’ managerial instability has further complicated matters. The sacking of Igor Tudor and subsequent appointment of Luciano Spalletti—renowned for his Serie A success with Napoli—brought hope but also tactical mismatches. Spalletti’s preference for a back-four clashes with Juventus’ squad, which is structured for a 3-4-3 system. Consequently, both David and McKennie have been forced to adapt to shifting roles.

Mixed Results Under Spalletti

Spalletti’s early tenure has produced inconsistent results. Juventus managed a narrow win over Cremonese, followed by a string of draws before the Champions League turnaround. Tactical tweaks—like deploying Teun Koopmeiners in defense to accommodate a crowded midfield—have yet to yield consistent attacking returns.

For McKennie, Spalletti’s arrival has meant regular starts, mostly as a right wing-back or advanced midfielder. The American’s reliability is clear—he has played nearly every minute under the new coach. But until his recent goal, his contributions were steady rather than spectacular, often rating a dependable 7/10 without headline-grabbing moments.

Jonathan David’s Juventus Challenge

David’s Juventus experience has been even more challenging. Signed amid competition from top clubs, the Canadian forward has struggled for game time. He’s started just five of eleven Serie A matches, with only a single league goal and assist to his name. Under Spalletti, David hasn’t started domestically and saw just brief Champions League action—despite impressive underlying statistics for shot creation and passing.

His late goal against Bodo/Glimt was a reminder of his striking instincts, but whether this marks a turning point for his Juventus career remains uncertain. The club’s tactical setup, heavily favoring traditional strikers, does not naturally accommodate David’s skill set as a roaming, versatile forward.

International Roles Remain Strong

Despite club struggles, both players remain crucial for their national teams. Canada’s manager, Jesse Marsch, lauds David as his most complete striker—capable of much more than just scoring. David’s versatility and intelligence make him indispensable for the Canadian setup, regardless of his Juventus minutes.

McKennie’s international situation is more delicate. Though a regular under Spalletti at club level, he was omitted from the latest U.S. squad as coach Pochettino encouraged him to solidify his club role. The message was clear: McKennie’s USMNT place is not under threat, but his starting status is not guaranteed either, especially with fierce competition in midfield.

Juventus’ Unstable Environment

Much of the difficulty for both Jonathan David and Weston McKennie stems from the turbulence at Juventus. The club’s hasty managerial changes and squad inconsistencies have left players fighting for stability. Spalletti’s tactical preferences clash with the existing squad dynamics, making it difficult for either CONCACAF star to shine consistently.

McKennie, whose contract expires at season’s end, faces an uncertain future—with MLS rumors swirling yet again. David, meanwhile, must prove he can adapt, or risk being a fringe player at club level heading into the World Cup.

What Lies Ahead for David and McKennie at Juventus?

Jonathan David and Weston McKennie epitomize the modern footballer’s paradox: essential for their countries, peripheral for their clubs. McKennie’s adaptability ensures he remains in Juventus’ plans, even if he lacks a fixed role. David’s national team status is unshakeable, but Juventus’ tactical rigidity limits his potential impact.

As the 2026 World Cup approaches, both players must turn these rare moments of brilliance into regular contributions for Juventus. Their performances on Tuesday showed they have the quality to deliver when it matters. If Juventus can find tactical cohesion—and if Spalletti adapts to his squad’s strengths—both could finally flourish in Turin.

For more news on international football and updates on CONCACAF stars, visit for more news.

Opinion: Time for Juventus to Back Their Stars

Ultimately, Jonathan David and Weston McKennie have proven they can be difference-makers on Europe’s biggest stage. Juventus must provide them with the consistent roles and tactical support they need to thrive. If not, both Juve and their national teams could miss out on the best these CONCACAF talents have to offer.