Michael Carrick Is the Right Interim Choice for Manchester United

Michael Carrick has emerged as the right choice for the Manchester United interim managerial role, surpassing Ole Gunnar Solskjaer in both credentials and suitability for the club’s pressing needs. As United stumbles through another turbulent season, Carrick’s appointment brings a sense of steady leadership that Old Trafford desperately requires.

Manchester United’s Managerial Turmoil and the Need for Stability

Since Sir Alex Ferguson’s departure, Manchester United has cycled through managers in search of a new era of dominance. Most recently, Ruben Amorim’s brief tenure ended in disappointment, culminating in United’s worst Premier League finish and further European heartbreak. His rigid tactical approach and public criticisms of the board exposed deeper structural issues within the club’s hierarchy, now heavily influenced by CEO Omar Berrada, director of football Jason Wilcox, and the INEOS ownership.

With Champions League aspirations slipping away and underwhelming domestic performances, United needed a caretaker manager to restore pride and unity. Reports indicated the interim battle was between two club legends: Solskjaer and Carrick. Ultimately, Carrick’s recent achievements and coaching demeanor made him the clear favorite.

Michael Carrick’s Impactful Track Record

Carrick’s coaching journey, which began at United as Solskjaer’s assistant, has been marked by professionalism and respect. During his short stint as United’s caretaker in 2021, he secured a Champions League win at Villarreal, a draw at Chelsea, and a thrilling victory over Arsenal. Players like Harry Maguire publicly praised his leadership and the respect he commanded within the squad.

Moving to Middlesbrough, Carrick transformed the club’s fortunes, guiding them from the brink of relegation to the Championship play-offs in his first season. His attacking philosophy rejuvenated Boro, earning both EFL Manager of the Month awards and unwavering support from players. Although the following season ended with disappointment, Carrick’s win percentage and the style of play he instilled left a lasting mark.

Why Carrick Is a Better Fit Than Solskjaer

Solskjaer’s United legacy is undeniable, particularly for his role in the 1999 Champions League triumph. His initial impact as interim manager in 2018 was also impressive, but his tenure eventually faltered due to tactical limitations and an inability to adapt. The Ronaldo return further complicated his approach, and a heavy defeat to Liverpool sealed his fate in 2021.

While Solskjaer’s experience is valuable, Carrick’s tactical acumen and calm authority are better suited for United’s immediate needs. As Solskjaer himself admitted, Carrick possesses impeccable values and knowledge, commanding respect from both players and staff. Crucially, Carrick views the interim position as a short-term assignment, focused on stabilizing the team rather than seeking a permanent post.

Carrick’s Leadership and Manchester United’s Future

Carrick’s return to Old Trafford is timely, as United faces a critical juncture. The team is still within reach of the top five, which could secure Champions League football, but consistency remains elusive. Recent results—draws against lower-table sides and early exits from domestic cups—underscore the need for a steady hand.

Darren Fletcher, who briefly stepped up as interim after Amorim’s departure, recognized that a new voice was needed to rally the squad. Fletcher himself may join Carrick’s backroom staff, echoing the collaborative environment that benefited United during previous transitional periods.

Rebuilding Respect and a Platform for Success

Respect is a key factor in the success of any interim manager. Carrick left a strong impression during his past coaching spells at United and Middlesbrough, with players lauding his trust, tactical clarity, and man-management. His ability to communicate with former teammates as authority figures sets him apart in the dressing room.

While United’s current squad faces limitations and lacks week-to-week consistency outside of stars like Bruno Fernandes, Carrick’s approach can reinvigorate morale and bring cohesion. The immediate goal is not wholesale transformation, but providing fans and players with renewed belief and a competitive edge for the remainder of the season.

Opinion: Michael Carrick Is the Sensible Interim Solution

In my view, appointing Michael Carrick as interim manager is a pragmatic and forward-thinking decision for Manchester United. He embodies the club’s values, offers tactical flexibility, and brings proven leadership that resonates with the current squad. Turning back to Solskjaer would be a step backward, signaling a lack of progress and learning from past mistakes. Carrick’s appointment is about stabilizing a turbulent campaign and setting a positive platform for the future, as United prepares for a permanent managerial overhaul in the summer.

For more news on Manchester United and football worldwide, visit for more news.