Messi vs Ronaldo: Ex-Real Madrid Star Garay Declares Messi the GOAT

Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo: The Ultimate Debate

Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo remains one of football’s most enduring debates. Few are better placed to weigh in than Ezequiel Garay, the ex-Real Madrid and Argentina defender who played with both icons at club and international level. Garay has recently shared his perspective on who truly deserves the ‘Greatest of All Time’ (GOAT) distinction.

Garay’s Unique Insight: Playing Alongside Messi and Ronaldo

Ezequiel Garay’s football journey is unique. Between 2008 and 2011, he wore the famous white of Real Madrid, closely observing Cristiano Ronaldo as he began his record-breaking journey with Los Blancos. Garay also accumulated 32 caps for Argentina, including U20 World Cup glory in a squad featuring a young Lionel Messi.

This rare exposure to both superstars provides Garay with an informed angle on the Messi vs Ronaldo discussion. When asked to pick between the two, Garay offered a candid and precise answer: “Number one is Leo and number two is Cristiano, without a doubt. They are two very different players, but the one who has surprised me the most is Leo. I have been fortunate enough to play with both of them, and Leo is something else.”

Messi vs Ronaldo: Different Paths to Greatness

Garay elaborates that in “pure football terms,” Lionel Messi stands above Cristiano Ronaldo, emphasizing Messi’s natural aptitude and gift for the game. He highlights how Messi is blessed with innate talent, making extraordinary moments look effortless—a quality that continues to dazzle fans and teammates alike.

However, Garay also pays respect to Cristiano Ronaldo’s relentless discipline and professionalism. Ronaldo’s unmatched work ethic and drive to succeed are legendary across the football world. “The story that Carlos Tevez always tells is true,” Garay confirms. “Cristiano is the first to arrive at 6 am and the last to leave. He starts his routine, his gym session, his warm-up, his physio… all that to always be in the best condition.”

Tevez and Garay: Messi’s Natural Brilliance vs Ronaldo’s Relentless Drive

Carlos Tevez, another star who has shared dressing rooms with both legends, echoes Garay’s observations. Tevez has often said that while Ronaldo worked tirelessly to reach the summit, Messi was simply born to play football. “Cristiano had to work and prepare himself to be the best; it comes natural for Leo,” Tevez remarked. This difference, in the eyes of both Tevez and Garay, is what tips the scales in Messi’s favor when discussing the GOAT status.

Messi’s Ballon d’Ors and Ronaldo’s Record-Breaking Feats

While Garay’s verdict supports Messi as the GOAT, he is quick to acknowledge Ronaldo’s monumental achievements. Ronaldo’s record as Real Madrid’s all-time top scorer and his collection of five Ballon d’Or trophies reflect an unyielding determination and a career sculpted through dedication. Messi, meanwhile, boasts eight Ballon d’Ors, further solidifying his long-standing reign at the pinnacle of world football.

Continuing the Legacy: Messi and Ronaldo’s Current Journeys

Despite being in the twilight of their careers, Messi and Ronaldo remain highly influential on the global football stage. Ronaldo is contracted with Al-Nassr in Saudi Arabia until 2027, and Messi has committed to MLS Cup winners Inter Miami through 2028. Both legends are widely expected to represent their nations at the upcoming World Cup, seeking yet more glory.

Rumors have even circulated about a potential reunion in Major League Soccer, as Ronaldo’s future in the Middle East comes under speculation. Whether or not that happens, their legacies are firmly entrenched in football history.

Messi vs Ronaldo in the GOAT Debate: Garay’s Take

Returning to the Messi vs Ronaldo debate, Garay’s testimonial carries weight due to his firsthand experiences with both players. His conclusion—Messi as the GOAT, Ronaldo as a close second—mirrors the sentiment of many footballers who have shared the pitch with the pair.

Garay’s words also underscore a broader truth: while raw talent and relentless work ethic can both elevate a footballer to greatness, it is rare for one player to embody both as completely as Messi and Ronaldo have in their own unique ways.

Opinion: Talent or Tenacity—What Defines the GOAT?

The Messi vs Ronaldo debate ultimately boils down to what fans value more: God-given talent or unrelenting perseverance. Messi enchants with his artistry and natural ability; Ronaldo inspires with his tireless ambition. Both are GOATs in their own right, but as Garay and Tevez suggest, perhaps Messi’s effortless brilliance just edges the contest.

For more news and updates on football’s greatest stories, visit for more news.