Florian Wirtz Faces Premier League Reality After Liverpool Move

Florian Wirtz’s decision to join Liverpool over Manchester City or Bayern Munich has sparked considerable debate, especially as the German international grapples with the demands of the Premier League. The talented midfielder, once tracked by Europe’s elite, now finds himself at the center of scrutiny as he adapts to life at Anfield.

Florian Wirtz’s Transfer Choice: Why Liverpool Over Man City?

Florian Wirtz had options aplenty after his standout performances for Bayer Leverkusen. While Real Madrid was an attractive prospect, the transfer was never on the table due to Xabi Alonso’s limited influence over signings at the Bernabeu. Wirtz was left to decide between Manchester City, Bayern Munich, and Liverpool. Ultimately, he was persuaded by Liverpool’s vision, the allure of Anfield, and manager Arne Slot’s promise of a pivotal role in the midfield.

The deciding factor was Slot’s detailed plan to make Wirtz integral to Liverpool’s attack. Unlike at Bayern, where competition with Jamal Musiala was a concern, or at City, where Pep Guardiola’s long-term future was uncertain, Wirtz saw a clear path to a starring role at Liverpool.

Florian Wirtz in Liverpool’s System: A Challenging Start

Wirtz began the 2025/26 season as Liverpool’s starting No.10 but struggled to make an immediate impact in the Premier League. Despite featuring in the first four matches, he failed to register a goal or assist, drawing criticism from fans and media alike. High expectations, fueled by his £100 million price tag, made his adaptation even tougher.

The challenge for Wirtz intensified as Liverpool’s form dipped. He became an easy scapegoat, despite the team’s broader issues with set-piece defending and inconsistency. Critics, including Wayne Rooney, questioned Wirtz’s fit within Liverpool’s preferred 4-3-3 formation, suggesting that Dominik Szoboszlai offered a better tactical balance.

Szoboszlai’s Rise Compounds Wirtz’s Struggles

Dominik Szoboszlai, last season’s engine in Liverpool’s midfield, has hit the ground running again. With crucial goals and assists, including a match-winning free-kick against Arsenal, Szoboszlai’s form has cemented his status as a starter. Meanwhile, Wirtz’s inability to directly contribute to goals has seen him fall behind in the pecking order for big matches, including the high-profile clash against Manchester City.

Manchester City: The Opportunity Wirtz Passed Up

Many believe that Florian Wirtz could have slotted seamlessly into Manchester City’s system, potentially as Kevin De Bruyne’s successor. Pep Guardiola had earmarked Wirtz as a key target, and the German’s attributes fit perfectly into City’s attacking setup. However, concerns over Guardiola’s contract and City’s reluctance to meet the £100 million fee saw the deal stall.

City ultimately turned to Rayan Cherki, who has already made a significant impact in Manchester with eight goal involvements, further fueling debate that City would have offered Wirtz a smoother transition into English football.

The Price Tag Debate: Is Criticism of Wirtz Fair?

Former City star Ilkay Gundogan and ex-Liverpool midfielder Danny Murphy have defended Wirtz, emphasizing that adaptation takes time and that his creative contributions remain high, particularly in the Champions League. Statistically, Wirtz has created more chances than any other player in the tournament, highlighting his value beyond basic goals and assists.

Florian Wirtz’s Potential in the Premier League

It’s clear that Florian Wirtz is still adjusting to the Premier League’s unique demands, but his underlying numbers suggest a player on the cusp of a breakthrough. He has been especially effective in Champions League matches, excelling in chance creation, pressing, and possession recovery. While his Premier League form lags behind expectations, patience may yet reveal his true potential at Liverpool.

Wirtz’s limited involvement in Liverpool’s strongest domestic performances may be concerning, but both Arne Slot and team leaders remain confident in his long-term value. Observers point out that Wirtz’s intelligence, technical quality, and eye for the creative pass will eventually translate to consistent success in England.

Opinion: Liverpool Still the Right Place for Wirtz’s Growth

While Florian Wirtz’s adaptation has been slower than anticipated, dismissing his potential as a misfit is premature. The Premier League has challenged many great imports, and Wirtz’s creativity and vision remain assets Liverpool cannot afford to overlook. Slot’s tactical flexibility may eventually unlock Wirtz’s best role, especially as the squad evolves and Mohamed Salah’s future is clarified.

For those following the journey of this “once-in-a-century talent,” patience is key. Wirtz may yet become the heartbeat of Liverpool’s midfield, proving that even a rocky start can lead to a glittering Anfield career. For more updates on this story and others, visit for more news.