Idrissa Gueye Red Card Headlines Everton’s Turbulent Night

Idrissa Gueye red card controversy dominated Everton’s difficult evening at Old Trafford as the Toffees midfielder was astonishingly sent off after a heated altercation with his own teammate, Michael Keane, during their Premier League clash against Manchester United.

Early Drama: Idrissa Gueye Red Card Shocks Supporters

Idrissa Gueye’s red card came just 13 minutes into the match. Following a tense moment after Manchester United narrowly missed a scoring opportunity, Gueye lost his composure and confronted defender Michael Keane. Cameras captured Gueye appearing to strike Keane in the face, and referee Tony Harrington wasted no time in showing a straight red card for violent conduct. The Premier League rapidly confirmed the decision on social media, stating that VAR had checked and agreed with the referee’s assessment, noting that Gueye’s action was “a clear strike to the face of Keane.”

Comparisons to Infamous On-Field Teammate Clashes

The Idrissa Gueye red card incident immediately drew parallels to the infamous 2005 clash between Newcastle United teammates Lee Bowyer and Kieron Dyer. Such confrontations are rare in football but tend to capture global attention due to their bizarre nature. Monday night’s spectacle left fans and pundits alike stunned by the scenes unfolding among Everton’s own ranks.

On Sky Sports commentary, Manchester United legend Gary Neville expressed his disbelief: “There’s a coming together between Gueye and Keane. It’s always unsavoury when it’s teammate on teammate. Idrissa Gueye has gone towards Michael Keane, who hasn’t really reacted. It didn’t look like much was in it, and Jordan Pickford did well to try and calm things down.”

Fan Reactions: Outrage and Sarcasm on Social Media

The decision sent shockwaves through the football community, with fans taking to social media to express their frustration and disbelief. Some called the red card excessive, arguing that a yellow would have sufficed, while others joked about getting cameras into the Everton dressing room to capture the fallout between Gueye and Keane.

One user referenced the Bowyer-Dyer fight, while others questioned whether similar incidents between Manchester United players would have drawn the same punishment. The overarching sentiment was summed up by the phrase “Game’s gone,” as many supporters lamented what they saw as an overreaction by the officials.

Everton’s Unwanted Red Card Record Grows

This latest Idrissa Gueye red card means Everton have now matched Arsenal’s record for the most red cards in Premier League history at 110. According to BBC Sport, Gueye also became the first player since 2008 to be dismissed in the Premier League for fighting with a teammate, following the infamous incident involving Stoke City’s Ricardo Fuller and Andy Griffin.

The laws of the game are clear: striking another person on the head or face with the hand or arm is a sending-off offense unless the force used is deemed negligible. Yet, even pundits like Neville questioned whether Gueye’s actions truly warranted a straight red: “Was it negligible? That’s the question. I think it was negligible. They weren’t fighting; it could have been handled with a yellow.”

What This Means for Everton’s Season

The repercussions of the Idrissa Gueye red card could be significant for Everton as they look to recover from this setback. With a man down from the 13th minute, the Toffees faced an uphill battle against a strong Manchester United side. The incident also raises questions about team unity and discipline, factors that are crucial as Everton prepare for their next fixtures.

Ruben Amorim’s Manchester United now look ahead to an away trip to Crystal Palace, while David Moyes’ Everton will try to regroup as they host Newcastle United at Goodison Park. The Toffees must quickly address the internal issues highlighted by the Gueye-Keane altercation if they are to avoid further disruption in an already challenging campaign.

Opinion: The Idrissa Gueye Red Card Sets a Precedent

In my view, the Idrissa Gueye red card puts the spotlight on how football’s disciplinary rules are interpreted in high-pressure scenarios. While the letter of the law might support the sending off, the context—a moment of frustration between teammates rather than outright violence—suggests a yellow card would have been more appropriate. With emotions running high and the stakes elevated, it’s up to referees to show both consistency and a sense of the game’s spirit.

For more news on Premier League drama, player incidents, and all things football, visit for more news.