Inter Miami’s Struggles Raise MLS Cup Contender Doubts

Inter Miami’s recent run of form has cast significant doubt on their credentials as MLS Cup contenders. The Herons endured their second consecutive 3-0 defeat, this time at the hands of Charlotte FC, leaving fans and pundits alike questioning whether Lionel Messi’s magic alone can keep their trophy ambitions alive.

Inter Miami’s Troubles: Form and Confidence Hit

Inter Miami entered the weekend hoping to bounce back from a tough 3-0 loss to the Seattle Sounders in the Leagues Cup final, but the match against Charlotte FC only deepened their woes. Messi, usually so reliable under pressure, attempted a panenka penalty that fell harmlessly into the goalkeeper’s arms—a moment that seemed to encapsulate the team’s current lack of confidence and direction.

Charlotte’s comprehensive victory was a fair reflection of the game. Miami struggled in the attacking third, rarely threatening and looking disjointed throughout. Defensively, they failed to cope with Charlotte’s aggression and pace, conceding three goals that reflected both organizational lapses and mental fatigue.

MLS Cup Contenders? Assessing Inter Miami’s Chances

Given the expectations surrounding Inter Miami at the start of the season—especially after Lionel Messi’s arrival—these back-to-back 3-0 losses have left supporters wondering if the team is built to challenge for major silverware in 2025. Messi’s undeniable talent keeps hope alive, but recent performances suggest deeper issues.

Manager Javier Mascherano’s tactics have come under scrutiny. While Messi remains the team’s focal point, there’s growing concern that Miami have become overly reliant on their Argentine superstar. When Messi is neutralized, as Charlotte managed to do, the team struggles to create meaningful chances. The midfield lacks creativity, and the defense has shown vulnerabilities that top MLS sides are quick to exploit.

Mascherano’s Approach and Squad Depth Under the Microscope

Inter Miami’s problems go beyond just form and confidence. Critics point to Mascherano’s tactical rigidity and the lack of rotation in the squad. Fatigue seems to be setting in as the season progresses, with the same core players expected to deliver week in, week out. Injuries and suspensions have further exposed the lack of depth, and younger squad members have yet to prove themselves as reliable options.

Despite a strong start to the season and the optimism brought by Messi’s presence, Miami’s current trajectory is worrying. The team’s struggles in front of goal and defensive frailty have created an urgent need for tactical and personnel adjustments if they are to remain in contention for the MLS Cup.

Hope Remains with Messi—But Is It Enough?

For all their issues, Inter Miami still possess the league’s most influential player in Messi. His ability to change games singlehandedly means Miami can never be counted out. However, the reliance on moments of brilliance rather than structured team play has made them predictable to well-organized opponents.

The upcoming rematch against Seattle Sounders at home provides an opportunity for Miami to respond and regain momentum. A positive result could help restore confidence, but anything short of a convincing performance will only deepen the concerns about their status as MLS Cup favorites.

Opinion: Inter Miami Must Evolve Beyond Messi

In my view, Inter Miami’s recent setbacks are a wake-up call. Success in Major League Soccer demands squad depth, tactical flexibility, and collective resilience—qualities that currently seem lacking. While Messi’s presence gives them hope, true title contenders need more than star power. Mascherano must adapt his approach and empower other players to step up if Inter Miami’s MLS Cup dreams are to stay alive.

For more analysis and the latest updates on Major League Soccer, visit for more news.