Jack Grealish’s Man City Form Not Guardiola’s Fault, Says Nevin

Jack Grealish’s recent resurgence on loan at Everton has reignited debate over his performances at Manchester City, with former Chelsea winger Pat Nevin insisting Pep Guardiola is not responsible for the England star’s previous dip in form.

Jack Grealish’s Struggles at Manchester City Examined

Jack Grealish’s journey from Aston Villa star to Manchester City record signing was expected to elevate his career to new heights. However, his time at the Etihad has been met with mixed reviews, with many critics arguing that the creative flair and attacking instincts Grealish displayed at Villa have been stifled under Guardiola’s structured system.

Despite City’s continued Premier League dominance, Grealish has often struggled to secure a regular starting place, and questions have been raised about whether he fits into Guardiola’s tactical approach. Some fans and pundits have pointed fingers at the City boss, suggesting his meticulous style has “beaten the flair” out of Grealish.

Pat Nevin Defends Pep Guardiola Amid Jack Grealish Debate

However, Pat Nevin believes the narrative is misguided. Speaking in light of Grealish’s outstanding start to the new season on loan at Everton, Nevin insists Guardiola cannot be blamed for the winger’s struggles at City.

“Jack Grealish is a fantastic player, but sometimes transitions to bigger clubs come with unique pressures and expectations,” Nevin explained. “It’s not always the manager’s fault if a player’s form dips. At Manchester City, the competition for places is intense and the system demands different things. I think Grealish just needed a change of scenery to reignite his confidence.”

Everton Loan Spell Brings Grealish Back to Form

Grealish’s impact at Everton has been immediate and impressive. Operating with the freedom and responsibility reminiscent of his Villa days, he has contributed crucial goals and assists, instantly becoming a fan favourite. His performances have helped Everton to a strong start in both the Premier League and domestic cup competitions.

This turnaround has led many to re-examine the true reasons behind Grealish’s struggles at City. Rather than laying the blame solely at Guardiola’s feet, some analysts now suggest that the intense competition, tactical demands, and weight of the £100m transfer fee may have collectively contributed to a challenging adjustment period.

Jack Grealish’s Role and Future at Manchester City

With Grealish excelling at Goodison Park, attention now turns to his long-term future. If his form continues, Everton may consider making the move permanent, but Manchester City still view him as a valuable asset. Guardiola himself has spoken highly of Grealish’s attitude and professionalism, emphasizing that adaptation at a club like City takes time.

The winger’s Everton spell has also provided a timely reminder of his unique qualities—his dribbling, ball retention, and creativity—that made him so coveted in the first place. As Grealish continues to shine, the debate over whether City’s system stifles creative talents is certain to continue.

Opinion: Grealish Proves It’s About Fit, Not Fault

In my view, Jack Grealish’s resurgence at Everton demonstrates that footballers thrive when they find the right environment. Guardiola’s tactical approach is not for everyone, and players like Grealish may simply need a system that prioritizes their strengths. Blaming the manager ignores the complexities of team dynamics, player adaptation, and personal confidence. Grealish’s story is a reminder that form is a product of fit, not just fault.

For more news and comprehensive coverage of the latest football stories, visit for more news.