January Transfer Window Review: Best Deals, Worst Moves, and Josh Sargent’s Saga

January transfer window review coverage brings a comprehensive look at the latest moves, surprises, and disappointments across European football. This winter’s window might have lacked blockbuster transfers, but several key developments are set to shape the remainder of the season and beyond.

January Transfer Window Review: A Quiet But Impactful Month

The January transfer window review reveals a period characterized by restraint. After a record-breaking summer of spending, many clubs tightened their belts this winter, resulting in less headline-grabbing movement. Historic big spenders like Manchester City opted for relative caution, though they still managed to bolster their squad with two new starting-caliber signings.

One of the main talking points: Crystal Palace splashed out a club-record fee for Jorgen Strand Larsen, a striker with an unremarkable scoring record. Meanwhile, anticipated moves like Ricardo Pepi’s supposed transfer to Fulham fell through, partly due to injury, highlighting the unpredictability of the market.

The Best Move of the Transfer Window

Among the limited big moves, Endrick’s loan switch to Lyon stands out. The Brazilian prodigy, temporarily departing Real Madrid, has found the freedom to showcase his talent in Ligue 1. His strong performances could even put him in contention for a World Cup spot. While Real Madrid fans may feel mixed emotions, Endrick’s impressive form benefits all sides—Lyon, Brazil, and Madrid alike.

Another notable deal is Marc Guehi’s transfer to Manchester City. Though he’s yet to settle in fully, his presence promises to strengthen City’s backline for years, reflecting a long-term vision.

Worst Move of the Window

Crystal Palace’s hefty investment in Jorgen Strand Larsen raises eyebrows. Dropping $66 million on a player with limited top-level experience screams of desperation. With Wolves cashing in, Palace are left hoping for a quick return on investment—anything less would make this one of the costliest gambles in recent memory.

Elsewhere, failed moves also had significant repercussions. Jean-Philippe Mateta’s collapsed transfer, due to a late medical issue, left Crystal Palace unable to recoup funds and AC Milan without the attacking reinforcement they needed for a title push.

The Move That Didn’t Happen: Josh Sargent’s Transfer Saga

Josh Sargent’s bid to leave Norwich City dominated headlines, but a much-anticipated move to Toronto FC failed to materialize. Sargent, keen to depart and sitting out matches in anticipation, was left in limbo as Norwich rebuffed Toronto’s advances. While the MLS transfer window remains open, a deal now looks complicated, and Sargent faces a period of uncertainty that could hamper his development and USMNT prospects.

Deals That Could Have Shaken Things Up

Several transfers that didn’t happen could have reshaped the football landscape. Jhon Duran’s rumored moves across multiple leagues would have made for a fascinating story, but ultimately, he stayed put. Similarly, Ricardo Pepi’s potential leap to Fulham was halted by injury. While staying at PSV keeps him competitive, the Premier League challenge would have been ideal for his progress and U.S. national team ambitions.

American Stars and World Cup Prospects

The January transfer window review also highlights moves affecting U.S. national team hopefuls. Alex Freeman’s switch to Villarreal offers him exposure to a higher standard of competition. Should he break into the starting lineup, there’s a real argument for him to challenge Sergiño Dest for a World Cup starting spot.

Meanwhile, Damion Downs’ move to Hamburg marks a turning point after a frustrating spell at Southampton, potentially boosting his World Cup chances. Other American talents—Max Arfsten, Sebastian Berhalter, and Diego Luna—stayed in MLS, where strong starts to the season could keep them in the national team conversation.

Which Team Won the Window?

Atletico Madrid enjoyed a quietly successful window, improving their squad while posting a net profit. If Diego Simeone can harness the talents of new arrivals like Ademola Lookman, Atletico could be well-placed for the remainder of the season.

Manchester City also enhanced both their attack and defense with the signings of Antoine Semenyo and Marc Guehi, adding proven Premier League quality. Whether these moves will be enough to catch Arsenal is debatable, but City’s squad is certainly stronger post-January.

Opinion: What’s Next for Josh Sargent and a Cautious Market?

The January transfer window review underscores a shift toward caution among Europe’s elite, following last summer’s spending spree. Endrick’s loan to Lyon is the highlight, offering immediate returns and long-term upside. In contrast, Crystal Palace’s risky outlay for Strand Larsen could prove wasteful unless he adapts quickly.

Josh Sargent’s failed move is a cautionary tale: forcing a transfer without a firm exit plan rarely ends well. He and Norwich now face a delicate situation with the MLS window still open—a move could yet happen, but playing time and international ambitions hang in the balance.

For more detailed insights across world football, visit for more news.