Man City Player Ratings: Foden & Haaland Miss Costly in Newcastle Defeat

Manchester City player ratings took a hit at St James’ Park as Phil Foden and Erling Haaland’s disappointing finishing proved costly in a 2-1 defeat to Newcastle United—a result that puts real pressure on City’s Premier League title ambitions.

Man City Player Ratings: Foden’s Misses Haunt Title Hopes

Manchester City player ratings tell the story of a frustrating evening for Pep Guardiola’s side. Phil Foden, usually so reliable, missed a golden opportunity after combining well with Rayan Cherki, only to shoot wide with just Nick Pope to beat. Erling Haaland’s struggles continued, the Norwegian star squandering two clear chances, the most glaring coming after a precise Jeremy Doku through ball when Haaland sent his effort wide of the mark.

The first half set a frenetic pace, with both teams guilty of wastefulness. Newcastle’s Nick Woltemade tested Gianluigi Donnarumma, but the Italian keeper stood firm. Harvey Barnes, too, missed a sitter, side-footing wide from close range. Despite City’s penalty appeals—Foden tumbled under Fabian Schar’s challenge, and Doku’s shot struck Malick Thiaw’s arm—referee and VAR waved play on.

Newcastle’s Ruthlessness Exposes City’s Flaws

The second half saw Newcastle United seize their chances. Harvey Barnes atoned for his earlier miss, drilling the Magpies ahead in the 64th minute. City briefly rallied, drawing level as Ruben Dias’s shot deflected off Schar to beat Pope. But Newcastle pressed again; after Bruno Guimaraes hit the bar, Barnes tapped home the rebound. A lengthy VAR check confirmed the goal, and City failed to find a response in eight minutes of added time.

This result marked Manchester City’s fourth loss in their opening 12 league fixtures, allowing Arsenal to strengthen their grip on the title race. The defeat, coming on the eve of the North London Derby, was a bitter blow.

Individual Player Ratings: City’s Stars Underwhelm

Goalkeeper & Defence

• Gianluigi Donnarumma (5/10): Made key saves early but struggled with crosses, particularly in the build-up to Newcastle’s winner.
• Matheus Nunes (5/10): Effective going forward in the first half but struggled defensively against Barnes.
• Ruben Dias (6/10): Solid at the back, fortunate with his equalising goal.
• Josko Gvardiol (5/10): Vital goal-line clearance but frequently overrun by Newcastle’s quick breaks.
• Nico O’Reilly (6/10): Offered attacking impetus but his defensive lapse contributed to Newcastle’s opener.

Midfield

• Bernardo Silva (5/10): Failed to control the midfield and offered little support defensively.
• Nico Gonzalez (5/10): Outpaced and overpowered as Newcastle dominated central areas.
• Phil Foden (4/10): A night to forget—his sloppy finishing proved pivotal in the result and dented City’s title bid.

Attack

• Rayan Cherki (5/10): Created Foden’s big chance but struggled to make a consistent impact.
• Erling Haaland (4/10): Uncharacteristically wasteful in front of goal; his quest for a 100th Premier League goal continues.
• Jeremy Doku (7/10): City’s brightest spark, repeatedly troubling Newcastle’s defence and creating multiple opportunities.

Subs & Manager

• Savinho (5/10): Wild efforts off target, unable to change the game.
• Tijjani Reijnders (6/10): Injected urgency into City’s play late on.
• Oscar Bobb (5/10): Failed to recapture his heroics from previous matches.
• Omar Marmoush (N/A): Late substitution, little impact.
• Pep Guardiola (5/10): Must reflect on how City allowed so many chances; momentum from the Liverpool win has evaporated.

What’s Next for Man City?

Manchester City must quickly regroup as crucial fixtures against Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League and a demanding Premier League schedule await. The pressure is on Guardiola and his star players to rediscover their composure and clinical edge if they are to keep their title hopes alive.

For more detailed coverage and the latest updates, visit for more news.

Opinion: Time for City’s Stars to Step Up

Watching Manchester City’s performance at Newcastle, it’s clear that even the best teams can falter when their biggest names misfire. Phil Foden and Erling Haaland missing big chances on the same night is rare—perhaps a blip, but also a warning sign as the title race heats up. Now, City’s leaders must show resilience and turn frustration into fuel if they’re to close the gap on Arsenal and reclaim Premier League supremacy.