Man Utd’s Benjamin Sesko Transfer Draws Criticism Amid Watkins Debate

Benjamin Sesko’s arrival at Manchester United has ignited debate among fans and pundits, as a treble-winning former Red Devils player questioned whether the club is taking another risky gamble akin to their recent signing of Rasmus Hojlund.

Benjamin Sesko Signing: A Risky Move for Manchester United?

Benjamin Sesko, the talented Slovenian striker, joins Manchester United after an impressive season at RB Leipzig, scoring 13 Bundesliga goals. While his potential is undeniable, the move has sparked concerns among United legends and supporters about whether he is ready to shoulder the attacking burden at Old Trafford.

A treble-winning ex-Manchester United star expressed reservations, comparing this transfer to the gamble the club took with Rasmus Hojlund last season. “It’s a big ask to bring in another young striker with limited top-flight experience,” the former player remarked, suggesting that United’s pattern of investing in raw prospects may not yield immediate results.

Why Wasn’t a Proven Striker Like Ollie Watkins Targeted?

The criticism intensified as attention turned to Premier League star Ollie Watkins. The England international, fresh off a prolific season with Aston Villa, was reportedly available but overlooked in favour of Sesko. “A more established striker like Watkins would bring guaranteed goals and leadership,” the former United player added, highlighting Watkins’ Premier League experience as a key differentiator.

Manchester United’s transfer policy has come under scrutiny after missing out on other attacking targets such as Hugo Ekitike. Given the club’s struggles with consistency up front, many fans and ex-players alike are questioning whether another youthful gamble will pay dividends.

Lessons from Rasmus Hojlund’s First Season at United

The club’s previous investment in youth, highlighted by Rasmus Hojlund’s transfer, has been a mixed bag. Hojlund showed flashes of brilliance but struggled for regular service and support, leading critics to argue he was somewhat “let down” by the club’s overall strategy and lack of experienced strike partners. The parallels with Sesko’s situation are hard to ignore.

Benjamin Sesko’s Strengths and What He Brings to Old Trafford

Despite the skepticism, Benjamin Sesko brings physical presence, aerial ability, and a strong work ethic. Still only 21, he has time on his side to develop into a top-class forward. United’s faith in his potential mirrors their approach with other young talents, betting on future success rather than instant impact.

Sesko’s supporters point to his goal-scoring record in Germany and his performance for the Slovenian national team as evidence that he can rise to the Premier League challenge. However, the intensity and physicality of English football present a new test.

What Does This Transfer Mean for Manchester United’s Attack?

Manchester United’s decision to sign Benjamin Sesko will shape their attacking options for the upcoming campaign. The move also signals the club’s ongoing commitment to youth development, even as calls grow louder for a more balanced approach blending youthful talent with proven experience.

The Red Devils will hope that, with better supply and a clear tactical plan, Sesko can settle quickly and make a significant contribution. Success will depend on how well he adapts and whether United can avoid repeating past mistakes in nurturing young prospects.

Opinion: Is Manchester United Taking the Right Approach?

In my view, Manchester United’s choice to invest in Benjamin Sesko over a seasoned Premier League striker like Ollie Watkins is a bold one, but it carries clear risks. The club must ensure that lessons are learned from the Hojlund experience—Sesko will need tactical support, patience, and perhaps a more experienced partner up front to thrive. For more news on Manchester United’s transfer strategy and Premier League updates, visit for more news.

Ultimately, the success of this transfer will be measured not just in goals scored, but in how Manchester United nurtures and integrates their new forward into the squad. If they can get the balance right, Sesko could become a future star at Old Trafford.