Manchester United Player Ratings vs Man City: Derby Day Disaster

Manchester United player ratings vs Man City headline a bleak derby day for the Red Devils, as Erik ten Hag’s side suffered a humbling 3-0 defeat to their crosstown rivals at the Etihad Stadium. The gulf in quality was stark, with United completely outclassed in every department and individual errors compounding an already disappointing start to the Premier League campaign.

Manchester United Player Ratings vs Man City: Defensive Collapse

Luke Shaw endured a torrid afternoon, being directly involved in all three Manchester City goals and struggling to contain the relentless City attack. His positioning and decision-making were repeatedly exposed, particularly for Phil Foden’s opener and Erling Haaland’s commanding second-half display. Shaw’s performance was emblematic of a Manchester United defence that looked disjointed and overrun by City’s pace and precision.

The back four as a whole failed to deal with the dynamism of Jeremy Doku, whose direct running caused panic throughout the match. Despite a lack of glaring blunders, Altay Bayindir – chosen over new arrival Senne Lammens – appeared uncertain, unable to inspire confidence at the back. Meanwhile, City’s goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma was the model of composure, making a crucial save to deny Bryan Mbeumo and highlight the contrast between the two teams between the posts.

Midfield and Attack Fail to Respond

Manchester United’s midfield was repeatedly overrun, unable to assert any control or link play forward, leaving Bruno Fernandes and Casemiro chasing shadows for much of the game. Sofyan Amrabat, in particular, struggled to disrupt City’s rhythm or offer meaningful cover for the defence.

Up front, Benjamin Sesko’s first start was disappointing. The Slovenian striker was largely anonymous, failing to trouble City’s defensive duo. His movement lacked purpose, and he received little service, which left United’s forward line blunt and ineffective. Marcus Rashford and Antony offered sporadic moments of promise, but lacked the cohesion and final product needed to challenge a well-drilled City defence.

Manchester United Player Ratings vs Man City: Individual Scores

– Altay Bayindir: 5/10 – No major errors, but lacked authority.
– Diogo Dalot: 5/10 – Overwhelmed by Doku’s pace.
– Raphael Varane: 5/10 – Outmuscled and often out of position.
– Lisandro Martinez: 5/10 – Struggled to cope with Haaland’s physicality.
– Luke Shaw: 3/10 – Directly responsible for multiple goals.
– Casemiro: 5/10 – Could not stem the City tide.
– Sofyan Amrabat: 4/10 – Failed to protect the defence.
– Bruno Fernandes: 5/10 – Unable to influence the game.
– Antony: 5/10 – Lacked effectiveness in attack.
– Marcus Rashford: 5/10 – Some lively moments, but no end product.
– Benjamin Sesko: 4/10 – Anonymous on his debut start.

Substitutes made little difference, as City controlled proceedings until the final whistle.

What This Means for United’s Season

This dismal result leaves Manchester United with just four points from their opening four fixtures, intensifying pressure on Erik ten Hag and the squad. With a difficult match against Chelsea looming, United’s defensive frailties and lack of attacking threat are ongoing concerns. It’s clear that significant improvement is needed across the pitch if United are to recover momentum in the Premier League.

Opinion: Urgent Need for Leadership and Tactical Clarity

The latest Manchester United player ratings vs Man City are a sobering reflection of the team’s current struggles. Defensive lapses, a lackluster attack, and a worrying absence of leadership on the pitch are all issues Ten Hag must address swiftly to avoid further setbacks. United’s fans will hope that this derby disaster serves as a wake-up call, prompting tactical adjustments and renewed commitment from the players. With tough fixtures ahead, the Red Devils must rediscover their resilience and quality – fast.

For deeper insights and the latest updates on Manchester United, visit for more news.