Manchester United’s Worst Moments Under Ruben Amorim

Manchester United’s tenure under Ruben Amorim will be remembered as one of the most turbulent in recent history. Despite flashes of progress, Amorim’s reign was defined by inconsistency, tactical confusion, and a string of painful setbacks that ultimately led to his departure. Below, we revisit the top ten worst moments that shaped Amorim’s ill-fated spell at Old Trafford.

Manchester United’s Painful Derby Defeat

Manchester United’s problems under Ruben Amorim came to the fore during the Manchester derby on September 14, 2025. Despite being above City in the standings early in the season, United were outclassed in a 3-0 defeat. The lack of attacking threat and continual defensive lapses highlighted the confusion with Amorim’s changing back three system, drawing criticism from pundits like Gary Neville.

Embarrassment at St. James’ Park

The 4-1 loss to Newcastle United epitomized United’s struggles in the league. Even after benching Andre Onana, defensive errors persisted, and the defeat confirmed the club’s lowest-ever Premier League points total. Amorim admitted to a lack of answers, fueling doubts about his leadership.

FA Cup Failure at Old Trafford

Hope in cup competitions quickly faded as United were knocked out of the FA Cup by Fulham in a penalty shootout at Old Trafford. This marked Amorim’s tenth defeat in 24 games—an alarming record compared to predecessors.

System Breakdown at Gtech Community Stadium

A 3-1 defeat to Brentford underscored issues with Amorim’s tactics. Players appeared uncertain in unfamiliar roles, leading to individual mistakes and disorganization. Pundits pointed the blame squarely at Amorim for a system that failed to suit the squad.

Three Consecutive Losses and Relegation Fears

Any momentum from a derby win over City was swiftly erased by three straight league defeats—against Bournemouth, Wolves, and Newcastle—without scoring a goal. Amorim openly acknowledged the risk of relegation, a shocking admission for a club of United’s stature.

Amorim’s Candid Admission: The “Worst United Team”?

After a humiliating 3-1 home defeat to Brighton, Amorim described his squad as “maybe the worst” in United’s history, citing just two wins in ten Premier League matches. His transparency was striking but did little to inspire confidence.

Collapse Against 10-Man Everton

A 1-0 defeat at home to Everton, who played with ten men for most of the game, further exposed United’s lack of intensity and cohesion. Amorim lamented the team’s absence of fighting spirit following another defensive meltdown.

Stalemate Against Wolves Continues Woes

Failing to beat struggling Wolves at Old Trafford, even after a morale-boosting win over Newcastle, highlighted United’s lack of creativity and inability to capitalize against weaker opposition. Amorim insisted better results would come with a full-strength squad, but time ran out.

Europa League Heartbreak in ‘El Crapico’

A promising Europa League run ended in bitter disappointment as United lost to Tottenham in the final, despite dominating possession and chances. The defeat, courtesy of a single Tottenham shot on target, was emblematic of defensive frailty throughout Amorim’s tenure.

The Grimsby Town Debacle: The Final Straw

Perhaps the most damaging moment came in the Carabao Cup, where United crashed out to League Two side Grimsby Town after a penalty shootout. Forced to bring on star players to salvage the tie, Amorim watched helplessly as his tactical adjustments failed and the team lacked intensity from the start—a moment that symbolized the end of his reign.

The End of an Era

Despite sitting sixth in the Premier League and showing improvement from last season’s 15th place, United’s board reluctantly decided to part ways with Ruben Amorim. His record-low 32% win rate in the Premier League era, coupled with persistent tactical confusion and public frustration, made his position untenable.

Opinion: Lessons for Manchester United’s Future

Manchester United’s experience with Ruben Amorim offers several lessons. Stability in tactics and a clear vision are essential for success at the highest level. United must now focus on rebuilding trust with their players and supporters, while ensuring their next appointment can bring consistency and effective leadership. For more news and updates on Manchester United’s next moves, visit for more news.