Marc Guehi’s Failed Liverpool Transfer Is a Win for All Sides

Marc Guehi’s failed Liverpool transfer has dominated the headlines after the Premier League champions were unable to finalize a deal with Crystal Palace on deadline day. While the England defender was left disappointed by the dramatic collapse, all parties—the player, Palace, and Liverpool—could ultimately benefit from this turn of events.

How the Marc Guehi Liverpool Transfer Saga Unfolded

Liverpool’s interest in Marc Guehi was no secret. With the Crystal Palace captain entering the last year of his contract and showing little desire to extend his stay at Selhurst Park, Palace were open to a deal. On deadline day, Liverpool reached a long-awaited agreement with Palace, setting the stage for a record-breaking move.

By late afternoon, Guehi was undergoing a medical in London, with both clubs having submitted the necessary paperwork to the Premier League. However, the transfer unraveled when Palace failed to secure a replacement—Igor Julio from Brighton chose West Ham instead—forcing the Eagles to pull out at the last moment.

Why the Transfer Collapse Could Benefit Marc Guehi

Though Marc Guehi was understandably frustrated at missing out on a big move to Liverpool, this setback could work in his favor. The defender has been a model professional on and off the pitch and now has the opportunity to reinforce his reputation as a leader at Crystal Palace. Remaining captain for another season gives him further responsibility and a chance to refine his skills in the Premier League spotlight.

If Guehi continues to perform at a high level, he will not only keep himself in the England squad but could attract even greater interest from other top clubs next summer—potentially on even better terms, both sporting and financial.

Crystal Palace Gain Stability by Retaining Guehi

From Crystal Palace’s perspective, holding on to Marc Guehi ensures defensive stability during a crucial campaign. Losing their captain without a suitable replacement would have risked derailing their season. By keeping Guehi, Palace have retained an influential figure who can inspire younger talents and help the club push for a strong Premier League finish.

Moreover, Guehi’s professionalism throughout the ordeal reinforces the positive culture at Palace, setting an example for the entire squad. This stability could pay dividends both on the field and in future transfer negotiations.

Liverpool’s Long-Term Planning Remains Intact

While Liverpool fans may be disappointed at missing out on their top defensive target, the club’s transfer policy remains methodical and forward-thinking. Rushing into a deal without all conditions met could have had repercussions for team chemistry and financial planning. By not forcing the transfer, Liverpool maintain their disciplined approach and can reassess their options in future windows, possibly revisiting Guehi or targeting other emerging talents.

Potential Outcomes for the 2024-25 Season

The failed transfer shapes the trajectories of all parties for the season ahead. Guehi remains a crucial part of Palace’s plans, offering leadership and quality at the back. Palace benefit from continuity and the opportunity to maximize their captain’s value. Liverpool, meanwhile, have shown patience—a trait that often pays off in the transfer market.

For more news and the latest updates on football transfers, head to for more news.

Opinion: Sometimes, the Deal That Doesn’t Happen Is the Best One

Transfers are often viewed through the lens of immediate winners and losers, but the collapse of Marc Guehi’s Liverpool move is a reminder that football careers—and club strategies—are marathons, not sprints. Guehi now has the chance to further solidify his legacy at Palace and position himself for a bigger move down the line, while both clubs retain flexibility heading into the next window. Sometimes, the best outcome comes from the deal that didn’t happen.