Marcus Rashford to Barcelona, Andy Carroll to Liverpool & the top 10 most ‘underserved’ transfers in football history

“If you assess where Marcus Rashford is at as a professional footballer, you strive as a youngster to get to the very top and play for clubs like Manchester United, and when you’re there, you appreciate it. You don’t throw it away and say you want to leave. I find the whole episode very soul-destroying,” United legend Teddy Sheringham told Sky Bet when asked for his opinion on Rashford’s imminent loan move to Barcelona.

“From my perspective, if you go from Manchester United to Barcelona, that’s a step up that he hasn’t deserved,” he added, and it’s impossible to disagree with that take when looking back at Rashford’s last two seasons on the Red Devils’ books. He managed just 11 Premier League goals in 48 appearances, broke disciplinary rules, and eventually lost his place in the team after Ruben Amorim was appointed manager, which led to Aston Villa signing the inconsistent attacker on loan in January.

Rashford instantly started playing with a smile again at Villa Park, helping Unai Emery’s side reach the Champions League quarter-finals and finish sixth in the Premier League, but he still only scored four goals, and it wasn’t much of a surprise that the Villans did not take up their £40 million ($54m) buy option on the 27-year-old. After so much early promise, Rashford had become damaged goods; an overpaid, overrated attacker who did have the right mindset to reach the very top.

Barca do not see it that way, though. The Spanish title holders believe Rashford is the final piece in the puzzle to bring them Champions League glory in 2025-26, and he will now form part of an all-star forward line alongside Lamine Yamal, Robert Lewandowski and Raphinha.

It feels like Rashford is the luckiest man in football, but is he about to seal the most “undeserved” transfer in football history? GOAL ranks the top 10 contenders for that unwanted title: