Mary Earps Braces for Mixed Reception in Manchester United Return

Mary Earps Faces Old Trafford Test After Manchester United Exit

Mary Earps is preparing for a highly anticipated return to Manchester United as her Paris Saint-Germain team travels to Old Trafford for a crucial Women’s Champions League clash. The England goalkeeper, who left Manchester United on a free transfer in 2024 after turning down a contract extension, expects a challenging atmosphere in her first match back since departing the Red Devils.

Why Mary Earps Left Manchester United

Earps’ decision to leave Manchester United came after a season of mixed emotions. Despite helping United to a historic FA Cup victory, the team endured its toughest Women’s Super League campaign to date. Earps made it clear that the club’s transitional phase did not align with her professional ambitions. Though Arsenal showed interest in signing her, she ultimately chose to pursue new challenges with PSG.

Anticipating the Old Trafford Atmosphere

Ahead of the Champions League fixture, Earps told BBC Sport, “I knew it from the moment United qualified. Sometimes you feel things are written in the stars.” She is under no illusion about the reception she may receive: “I’m probably expecting a little booing. I hope it’s a little bit, but it might be a lot.” Earps recalled how teammate Alessia Russo faced a wave of jeers when she returned with Arsenal, but acknowledges her own move to PSG, rather than a direct league rival, might soften fan reactions.

Factors That Could Influence the Response

A number of elements may affect how Manchester United fans respond to Earps. The sheer size of Old Trafford, as opposed to the more intimate atmosphere of the Progress With Unity Stadium, may dilute any hostility. Furthermore, Earps’ transfer to PSG—unlike Russo’s move to Arsenal—means she did not join a direct WSL competitor, which may mitigate negative feelings among supporters.

Issues stemming from Earps’ autobiography, including controversial comments about Chelsea’s Hannah Hampton, likely have little bearing on Manchester United fans. Additionally, the club had already anticipated her departure by signing Phallon Tullis-Joyce, who has since excelled as United’s first-choice goalkeeper and is now a nominee for the 2025 Best FIFA Women’s Goalkeeper award.

Manchester United’s and PSG’s Current Champions League Form

Manchester United enters the match in strong form, having secured victories against Valerenga and Atletico Madrid in their first two Champions League fixtures. In contrast, PSG has yet to earn a point after losses to Wolfsburg and Real Madrid, raising the stakes for Earps’ return to her former home ground.

Marc Skinner Welcomes Earps Back

United manager Marc Skinner, who worked with Earps during her teenage years at Leicester City, expressed only positive sentiments ahead of the reunion. “Me and Mary have always had a good relationship,” Skinner said. “From our perspective, we’ll welcome her as someone on the opposing team, but we will always pay tribute to her contributions to Manchester United.”

What’s Next for Mary Earps and Manchester United?

This highly charged encounter at Old Trafford is set to be a defining moment in both clubs’ Champions League campaigns. While United will aim for a third straight group win, Earps and PSG are desperate for points to revive their European hopes.

Opinion: Legacy Beyond Loyalty

Mary Earps’ return to Manchester United is more than just a football match—it’s a reflection of the passion fans feel for their club and the complexities of modern football careers. While some supporters may express disappointment or frustration, Earps’ professionalism and achievements deserve recognition. Her journey highlights how player decisions, even when difficult, are shaped by ambition and the evolving landscape of women’s football. For Earps and the fans, this fixture is about respect, legacy, and the enduring power of the game.

For more updates on this story and other top football headlines, visit for more news.