Mary Earps Faces Backlash Over Lionesses Legacy Controversy

Mary Earps finds herself at the heart of a heated debate as she returns to Manchester United, with her once-glowing Lionesses legacy now facing intense scrutiny. Once a national hero for her crucial role in England’s UEFA Women’s Euro 2022 triumph and the journey to the 2023 Women’s World Cup final, Earps confronts a wave of criticism following her recent comments about former teammate Hannah Hampton and England manager Sarina Wiegman.

Mary Earps’ Lionesses Legacy Under Threat

Just months ago, Mary Earps was celebrated as one of England’s finest goalkeepers, immortalized by her performances for the Lionesses. However, the release of her book “All In” and explosive interviews have cast a shadow over her achievements. The controversy centers on Earps’ reaction to losing her place as England’s No.1 goalkeeper to the talented Hannah Hampton. Her remarks about Hampton’s previous exclusion from the squad due to alleged “bad behaviour,” and her critique of Wiegman’s decision to reinstate Hampton, have divided fans and pundits alike.

Hannah Hampton and the Changing of the Guard

Hampton, now England’s first-choice keeper and a star for Chelsea, has handled her rise with professionalism, winning support from high-profile coaches such as Sonia Bompastor and Emma Hayes. Both have praised Hampton’s growth and character, dismissing any lingering doubts about her past conduct. In a recent interview, Hampton spoke respectfully of Earps, highlighting her impact on women’s football and expressing gratitude for the path her predecessor paved. In stark contrast, Earps’ book reopens old wounds, suggesting Hampton’s selection rewarded poor behaviour—claims Hampton’s supporters strongly refute.

Wiegman’s Leadership Defended

The current England manager, Sarina Wiegman, who was instrumental in reviving Earps’ international career, has also come under fire in Earps’ book. Earps questioned Wiegman’s transparency over team selections, further fueling the controversy. Top managers, including Bompastor and Hayes, have publicly defended Wiegman, emphasizing her professionalism and success, and calling on Earps to show respect for her teammates and coaches.

Public Perception and Fan Reaction

Social media has erupted with debate as fans react to the unfolding story. Many supporters feel Earps’ remarks were poorly timed, interpreted by some as bitterness following her demotion. Her abrupt international retirement, just before a major tournament, left England short on experienced goalkeepers and drew additional criticism. Supporters who once cheered Earps’ every save now express disappointment, believing her actions have tarnished an otherwise exemplary career.

Legacy Overshadowed by Controversy

The impact of Mary Earps’ words extends beyond the dressing room. Her criticisms have overshadowed the powerful subjects addressed in her book, such as mental health, body image, sexuality, and her fight to have replica goalkeeper kits available for fans. Yet, the narrative has become dominated by her rift with Hampton and Wiegman, causing many to question how she will be received when she steps onto the pitch at Old Trafford with Paris Saint-Germain in the upcoming Women’s Champions League clash.

Mary Earps’ Return to Manchester United: A Changed Reception?

When Earps left Manchester United at the end of her contract, she remained a beloved figure, having helped secure the club’s first major women’s trophy in the FA Cup final. The Football Association had planned a tribute to her international career, expecting a hero’s welcome. Now, with many fans voicing their disapproval, it remains to be seen how Earps will be greeted at Old Trafford and at future Lionesses’ tributes. The damage to her status among supporters is palpable, and her legacy may never fully recover.

Opinion: Perspective is Key in Football Legacies

While Mary Earps’ contributions to English football should never be forgotten, her recent actions serve as a reminder that legacy is shaped not just by achievements, but by attitude and respect for others. In a sport defined by teamwork and progression, humility and grace are often remembered just as vividly as moments of brilliance.

Visit for more news and the latest football updates.