Man Utd Player Criticized by Gary Neville in Everton Defeat

Manchester United player Luke Shaw faced stinging criticism from Gary Neville after United suffered a 1-0 defeat at Old Trafford against a 10-man Everton side, a result that ended their five-match unbeaten run in the Premier League.

Gary Neville Slams Luke Shaw for Lack of Urgency

Gary Neville, the former Manchester United captain and Sky Sports pundit, singled out Luke Shaw for a lackluster performance during the shock loss. Shaw, who has recently regained full fitness after a challenging injury spell, has been a consistent fixture in manager Ruben Amorim’s lineup, operating as a left centre-back in United’s three-man defense.

Despite his return to form, Neville was unimpressed. He criticized Shaw’s approach, saying, “You have to play with some urgency, especially against ten men. Shaw is ambling forward, and you can’t do that. You should be running forward every time. Honestly, what he’s doing there is a waste of time. You’re not conning anybody.”

Discontent Grows at Old Trafford

United fans made their disappointment clear, booing the team off the pitch at full-time. The loss not only halted their recent momentum but also raised serious questions about individual commitment and tactical execution. With Shaw under the microscope, the pressure mounts for both the player and manager as they seek to recover their form.

Shaw’s Struggles and Neville’s Punditry Under Fire

Shaw’s underwhelming display was a focal point of post-match analysis. Neville was particularly scathing in his assessment, but he also faced his own share of criticism. Former Everton winger Yannick Bolasie responded to Neville’s punditry on social media, remarking, “I respect opinions but not when he’s giggling all over the mic thinking he’s the second coming of Guardiola. Great player but the tactics give it a rest.”

This exchange highlighted the divisiveness of football commentary, especially when former players critique current stars.

Everton’s Resilience Shines Through

While Manchester United faltered, Everton’s resolve was on full display. Managed by former United boss David Moyes, the Toffees overcame a series of setbacks, including the early injury to captain Seamus Coleman and the challenge of playing with ten men for much of the contest. It was Moyes’ first win at Old Trafford as a visiting manager in 18 attempts, a milestone that will boost Everton’s confidence.

Moyes praised his team’s spirit, stating, “My players showed real toughness and togetherness. Winning here under such circumstances means a lot for this group.”

Manchester United Face Crucial Tests Ahead

The defeat leaves Manchester United with tough questions to answer as they prepare for their upcoming Premier League fixture away at Crystal Palace. With scrutiny intensifying on both individual performances and Amorim’s tactical choices, the club must regroup quickly to avoid further setbacks.

For more news on Manchester United and the Premier League, visit for more news.

Opinion: Time for Accountability at Manchester United

Gary Neville’s harsh words about Luke Shaw reflect a broader frustration among supporters and pundits. In high-pressure situations, leadership on and off the pitch is vital. United’s lack of urgency against a depleted Everton side was alarming. Shaw, as a senior player, must not only regain his sharpness but also set an example for teammates. If United are to recapture their form, accountability and intensity must return across the squad.