Man City Player Ratings: Guardiola’s Gamble Backfires Against Leverkusen

Manchester City player ratings reveal a night to forget as Pep Guardiola’s much-changed side suffered a 2-0 defeat to Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League. Marking his 100th European appearance at the helm, Guardiola’s bold decision to rest key stars like Erling Haaland, Phil Foden, and Ruben Dias ultimately proved costly.

Guardiola’s Risky Lineup Decision

Guardiola opted for 10 changes from his usual starting XI, fielding a team more reminiscent of a Carabao Cup fixture than a crucial Champions League tie. The exclusion of Haaland and Foden left City lacking attacking edge, while the defense struggled to find rhythm. Bayer Leverkusen capitalized on the inexperience and disjointedness, with Alex Grimaldo firing them ahead in the first half and Patrick Schick doubling the lead after the break.

Manchester City Player Ratings vs Bayer Leverkusen

James Trafford (4/10): Struggled to assert himself, conceding both shots faced. His decision-making came into question after a risky foray outside his box.

Abdukodir Khusanov (5/10): Overwhelmed defensively, failed to close down Grimaldo, and offered little going forward.

John Stones (6/10): One of the few to retain composure, his attempts to drive the ball forward stood out in an otherwise lackluster defensive display.

Nathan Ake (5/10): Rusty after a spell on the sidelines, failed to track Schick for the second goal.

Rayan Ait-Nouri (4/10): Out of sync with teammates, struggled both defensively and offensively, and was withdrawn at halftime.

Midfield Struggles Without Usual Leaders

Tijjani Reijnders (5/10): Lacked the composure expected of a City midfielder, missing a golden chance before halftime.

Nico Gonzalez (6/10): The only starter retained from City’s previous match, providing rare stability in an unsettled midfield.

Rico Lewis (4/10): Unable to impose himself, struggled to create or disrupt Leverkusen’s rhythm.

Forwards Fail to Ignite

Savinho (5/10): Inconsistent passing and wayward shooting contributed to City’s attacking frustrations.

Omar Marmoush (5/10): Struggled as the lone striker, unable to hold up play or convert his single opportunity.

Oscar Bobb (4/10): Failed to make an impression on a rare start, with predictable movement and poor end product.

Second-Half Substitutions Fail to Change the Game

Guardiola reacted to a dire first-half by making three changes at the break, bringing on Jeremy Doku and Phil Foden. However, the desired impact failed to materialize. Haaland and Rayan Cherki were introduced after the hour mark, but even their energy and intent could not undo Leverkusen’s grip on the match. Haaland was presented with two chances but could not find the net, and City never looked likely to mount a comeback after the second goal.

Manager Rating: Pep Guardiola (4/10)

Guardiola’s approach smacked of overconfidence, and the wholesale rotation was duly punished. His reluctance to field his best players from the outset undermined City’s chances, and the defeat leaves questions about prioritizing squad rotation at the expense of Champions League momentum.

Bayer Leverkusen’s Tactical Masterclass

Bayer Leverkusen, disciplined and ruthlessly efficient, exposed Manchester City’s vulnerabilities. Grimaldo’s precision in the first half and Schick’s opportunism after the break highlighted the contrast in sharpness, with Leverkusen seizing every opportunity.

What This Defeat Means for Manchester City

The loss marks a setback for Guardiola’s City, casting doubt on their European ambitions this season. With top players rested and squad depth exposed, the defeat serves as a stark reminder that even the biggest clubs must respect the pedigree of Champions League opposition.

For more news and comprehensive coverage of football, visit for more news.

Opinion: Lessons for Guardiola and City Moving Forward

This result should serve as a wake-up call for Guardiola and Manchester City. While rotation is necessary across a grueling schedule, the Champions League demands respect. Underestimating opponents by resting key figures can backfire, as it did here. In high-stakes European ties, fielding the strongest possible lineup remains crucial to upholding City’s ambitions on the continental stage.