Man City Player Ratings vs Newcastle: Marmoush Stars in Cup Semi

Manchester City player ratings vs Newcastle showcase why Pep Guardiola’s side are heading to Wembley, as a sparkling performance led by Omar Marmoush dispatched Newcastle 3-1 on the night and 5-1 on aggregate in the Carabao Cup semi-final. The focus now turns to a high-stakes final against Arsenal, but this dominant display will live long in the memory of City fans.

Man City Player Ratings vs Newcastle: Marmoush Leads the Way

Manchester City player ratings vs Newcastle opened with James Trafford making a statement in goal, earning an 8/10 for his composed performance. Trafford’s early interventions—denying Joe Willock and Anthony Gordon—set the tone, robbing Newcastle of early momentum and extending their dismal away record against City.

Matheus Nunes (6/10) showed flashes of class but was caught napping, while Abdukodir Khusanov (5/10) and Nathan Ake (5/10) struggled for composure and pace, respectively. Rayan Ait-Nouri was a bright spark, surging down the left and earning a 7/10.

Midfield Dominance Paves the Way

Nico O’Reilly delivered a commanding display in midfield, dictating play and forming a formidable partnership with Nico Gonzalez (7/10). O’Reilly’s strength and vision were crucial, meriting an 8/10. Phil Foden showed neat touches but didn’t stamp his authority as expected, rating a 6/10.

Clinical Attack Seals Wembley Date

Omar Marmoush was the standout performer, tormenting Newcastle with intelligent movement. Luck played a part in his opener, but he capitalized on defensive lapses to notch a brace—earning another 8/10 and cementing his reputation as a Magpie menace. Tijjani Reijnders (8/10) powered through the Newcastle defense for City’s second and found the net himself, while Antoine Semenyo (7/10) drove at defenders and set up Reijnders’ goal.

Newcastle’s Response and City’s Second-Half Management

Eddie Howe’s Newcastle did show spirit, with January signing Anthony Elanga producing a quality finish for his debut goal. Yet, even after half-time changes, the Magpies struggled for control. Guardiola, sensing any threat, brought on Rodri and Erling Haaland—who twice went close—to steady the ship and keep City’s grip on the match.

Subs and Manager Ratings

– Max Alleyne: 5/10 – Struggled after replacing Ake.
– Rodri: 6/10 – Helped regain midfield control.
– Erling Haaland: 7/10 – Immediate threat off the bench.
– Rayan Cherki: 7/10 – Injected flair in his cameo.
– Rico Lewis: N/A – Late sub.
– Pep Guardiola: 7/10 – Tactical mastery ensured the tie was never in doubt, though he’ll want sharper focus for Arsenal.

What’s Next for Manchester City?

With their 22nd trip to Wembley under Guardiola, Manchester City’s attention now turns to a showdown with Arsenal in the Carabao Cup final. The player ratings vs Newcastle reveal a squad brimming with depth, flexibility, and hunger for silverware. City will be favorites, especially if they display the same defensive solidity and attacking fluidity.

Opinion: City’s Strength in Depth Makes the Difference

Manchester City’s player ratings vs Newcastle reflect not just individual excellence but also the remarkable depth at Guardiola’s disposal. Even with rotation, City maintained control and intensity, underlining why they are favorites in every domestic competition. If they bring this form to Wembley, Arsenal will have their work cut out.

For more updates on Manchester City and the latest football action, visit for more news.